• Some users have recently had their accounts hijacked. It seems that the now defunct EVGA forums might have compromised your password there and seems many are using the same PW here. We would suggest you UPDATE YOUR PASSWORD and TURN ON 2FA for your account here to further secure it. None of the compromised accounts had 2FA turned on.
    Once you have enabled 2FA, your account will be updated soon to show a badge, letting other members know that you use 2FA to protect your account. This should be beneficial for everyone that uses FSFT.

Prey - 360 or PC?

Prey: 360 or PC?

  • 360

    Votes: 32 17.0%
  • PC

    Votes: 156 83.0%

  • Total voters
    188
PC, completely underwhelmed with what the 360 can do, i'll still try the 360 demo when it's plopped up on live marketplace.
 
awesome game on pc. I think/know my venice 3200 @2.5ghz is bottlenecking my dual 7900gtxs. Is this a game designed arund dual core technology?
 
Greenwit said:
I'm pretty sick of the PC upgrade cycle and video cards are becoming ridiculously expensive. Which is why I got the 360. I'll be playing it on my 50" HD plasma and will only consider a PC game if I can't get it on the 360.

lol that's ironic.. you're sick of expensive video cards, yet you have a FIFTY inch plasma tv and a 360 which costs upward of $600 once you factor in additional controllers, xbox live subscriptions, credits for XBLA, other accessories.. I think it's not expensive video cards that's the problem because consoles and HDTVs and lots of other things are expensive, it's just where you choose to put your money. anyway, i bet it will look awesome on that tv though :D
 
Techx said:
lol that's ironic.. you're sick of expensive video cards, yet you have a FIFTY inch plasma tv and a 360 which costs upward of $600 once you factor in additional controllers, xbox live subscriptions, credits for XBLA, other accessories.. I think it's not expensive video cards that's the problem because consoles and HDTVs and lots of other things are expensive, it's just where you choose to put your money. anyway, i bet it will look awesome on that tv though :D

The plasma is out of the gaming equation since I never even considered it for gaming when I bought it 14 months ago. Simple fact is that the 360 costs as much as a high end video card. And how would you rather game.......sitting with your face next to your computer screen at a desk or 9 feet away from a high def plasma with a wireless controller on your lap on a comfy couch playing a hi def widescreen game? (BTW, Xbox live is $50/yr....so what and the other accessories are not needed). 360 FTW.
 
Greenwit said:
The plasma is out of the gaming equation since I never even considered it for gaming when I bought it 14 months ago. Simple fact is that the 360 costs as much as a high end video card. And how would you rather game.......sitting with your face next to your computer screen at a desk or 9 feet away from a high def plasma with a wireless controller on your lap on a comfy couch playing a hi def widescreen game? (BTW, Xbox live is $50/yr....so what and the other accessories are not needed). 360 FTW.

Some people also like to sit in a big comfy (p)leather chair with the control and precision of a KB/M. I also prefer being closer to the screen, it brings me "into" the game more. It also helps that I have a 24" widescreen.

I have a 50" widescreen TV hooked up to my 360 yet I still prefer PC gaming. Thats why I preordered the PC version.

Different strokes for different folks...
 
Heeere we go again. Let the Idiots with Oversized Egos meeting #4,984,334 come to disorder.

:rolleyes:
 
Bop said:
Some people also like to sit in a big comfy (p)leather chair with the control and precision of a KB/M. I also prefer being closer to the screen, it brings me "into" the game more. It also helps that I have a 24" widescreen.

I have a 50" widescreen TV hooked up to my 360 yet I still prefer PC gaming. Thats why I preordered the PC version.

Different strokes for different folks...

I'm not giving up PC gaming entirely.....in fact I'm picking up Titan Quest for the PC on Tuesday. I'm just saying I'm sick of the upgrade cycle. For example, I didn't buy Fear because my rig, while it can handle it, won't give me smooth frames at high detail/resolution. I didn't buy FarCry for a long while for similar reasons. In fact throughout the years, there are many games that I wouldn't play because my hardware was not up to snuff. And I'm not going to buy a new video or CPU just to play the latest graphics demanding PC game.
 
I initially voted 360, because i think the overall experience would be more solid. Due to simpler setup no faffing etc. But after running the demo the PC in my sig (which ran very well at decent settings) I might get it for my PC. Undecided. But either way...it looks to be a great game.
 
Syphon Filter said:
I initially voted 360, because i think the overall experience would be more solid. Due to simpler setup no faffing etc. But after running the demo the PC in my sig (which ran very well at decent settings) I might get it for my PC. Undecided. But either way...it looks to be a great game.

I can't agree. Though I really enjoy playing games on my 52" DLP scree, I can't get over the game pad for playing FPS games. I've tried and I just can't stand it. Even beyond that, in many situations it just seems rediculous to me. Take Republic Commando for example. On the PC version certain droids, weapons or enemies in general can drop your shield in no time flat and kill you if you don't watch out. When you attack enemies, its much harder to get accurate shots off on them. It just looks rediculous to stand there and miss the targets with melee attacks up close. The damages enemies do to you is reduced just to balance the game so that you can get through it. On the PC version, it is a much different and much more "realistic" experience.

I have noted that with FPS's on consoles, the hit boxes are huge, damages reduced and auto aiming are required in order to hit the targets with any proficiency.

That is not a good experience to me. I love the simplicity of connecting a console and grabbing the game pad, but I don't think it works as well for FPS games. Racing games and things like that, I prefer on console.

Plus in this case, I'll take a $50 game over a $60 game. I can still always hook my PC up to my TV if I want to game on that.

BTW Prey actually supports the Logitech G15 keyboard. My health and Spirit meters showed up on the LCD display.
 
To those suggesting that the graphics between the PC and Xbox 360 versions are different, I would beg to differ. With the settings turned up all the way on my comp running at a custom res of 1280x720 (effectively 720p) versus the Xbox 360, I noticed absolutely no difference. I guess the reason to get the PC version would be if you have a monitor that supports higher resolutions or if you hate gamepad controls. I like gamepad controls for FPSs (I know, I'm weird), so I'm kind of neutral as to which one to get. The PC version is $10 cheaper, though.
 
Greenwit said:
For example, I didn't buy Fear because my rig, while it can handle it, won't give me smooth frames at high detail/resolution.

Yeah, because god forbid you play the game for the actual gameplay. :rolleyes:
 
jaguax said:
Yeah, because god forbid you play the game for the actual gameplay. :rolleyes:

Why not get actual gameplay and superb performance for a good price ? I've been an avid PC gamer for 16 years, and the Xbox 360 was by far the smartest gaming purchase I've made in probably 8-10 years.

Seriously.
 
fizzelopeguss said:
PC, completely underwhelmed with what the 360 can do, i'll still try the 360 demo when it's plopped up on live marketplace.

I am impressed what a $400 machine can do myself, the 360 is a great platform. But let's face it, if your computer can run it - KB+M FTW!!!
 
theNoid said:
Why not get actual gameplay and superb performance for a good price ? I've been an avid PC gamer for 16 years, and the Xbox 360 was by far the smartest gaming purchase I've made in probably 8-10 years.

Seriously.

I would agree with you, but right now I can't because there just are not enough good games on it right now. However, this time next year I will more than likely be in full agreement with you.. I hope anyway.
 
theNoid said:
Why not get actual gameplay and superb performance for a good price ? I've been an avid PC gamer for 16 years, and the Xbox 360 was by far the smartest gaming purchase I've made in probably 8-10 years.

Do you copy+paste this into every "which platform" thread? Perhaps you should put your 6800GT to use, since this game will surely play much better with a keyboard and mouse. And it's more customizable. And it's cheaper. Just think, buy 30 games at $10 more for the X360, and you've got a decent GPU for your PC right there!
 
vortexpud said:
And it's cheaper. Just think, buy 30 games at $10 more for the X360, and you've got a decent GPU for your PC right there!
Wow, you get todays bad logic award :p
 
Zinn said:
Wow, you get todays bad logic award :p

It was sarcasm, my friend :p
Though there are a lot of examples on that particular system that a game *IS* $10 more for NO particular reason. This is one of them.
 
Obi_Kwiet said:
Also, there is no reason to believe that the 360 version will be less buggy. With the advent of patches on the the 360 devs are lazier about making the final version of the game bug free.

Pure BS. Most patches are made to stop cheaters, not to fix a busted game. There is absolutely no comparison between the final products that get shipped for consoles and the final beta kits that get shipped to PCs.

vortexpud said:
Do you copy+paste this into every "which platform" thread?

He doesn't, but I'm fairly certain that you do.
 
so far the 360 hasn't impressed me. graphics should improve on it but my main issue is the damn controllers and the fact that I am an fps player. I need a mouse and keyboard.
 
I absolutely suck at first player FPS's... I ALWAYS GET lost and get really bored really fast. I'm not too shabby at CS:S but I cannot finisha a first player FPS for teh life of me. Where do you go at the bar? I wasn't really paying attention to what people were saying cause I had people over, but what are you supposed to do? Is the action any good in the game?

Oh, and I vote PC.
 
diehard said:
You sure about the "superior graphics" part? The Highest settings on the pc and 360 should be the same. Shouldn't a larger screen be a plus for the 360?

You've made two errors.

1. The highest resolution available will be on the PC.
2. That larger screen you've got your 360 hooked up to? Guess what? You could hook your PC up to it as well, so it isn't a factor. I run my pc through a projector for a 12 foot wide screen on a regular basis. :p
 
bildad said:
360. I don't play games on my PC anymore. I find I prefer playing cames on the couch with a controller. Even for fps I like the controller better. Feels more comfy and natural to me.

you can do that on a pc...
 
Can your PC run it well? That's the important question.
If you've got a PC fast enough to run it, it's certainly the best option.
How good is your 360 setup vs. your PC's setup?
Sure you can plug your PC into your TV, but it's a hell of a lot easier to hook up the Xbox seeing how that's how it was designed.
It really all comes down to your setup for both.
 
Eastvillager, you think most people are going to have their PCs in their living room next to their couches or something? Yes, you can hook a PC up to TV. Is this a good idea for computers that have any purpose beyond entertainment? No. You did it, good job. I'm glad you wrote three posts about it. I actually use my computer for work, so dragging into the living room away from my desk isn't going to happen.

Also, what's with extolling PCs for having higher resolution and then recommending that people hook them up to low resolution TVs (which typically support 720P at best)? That doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

We get that you're not a console gamer, but your wacky way of doing things isn't a legitimate substitute for owning a console in my eyes. I enjoy gaming on my PC but there is a difference between consoles and PCs in what they're useful for. I wouldn't want to substitute one for the other.
 
eastvillager said:
You've made two errors.

1. The highest resolution available will be on the PC.
2. That larger screen you've got your 360 hooked up to? Guess what? You could hook your PC up to it as well, so it isn't a factor. I run my pc through a projector for a 12 foot wide screen on a regular basis. :p
Dude im far too lazy to drag my pc upstairs every time i wanna play a game. Heck, im far too lazy to drag my pc upstairs even once, ever.
 
Back
Top