- Joined
- Jun 13, 2009
- Messages
- 10,336
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Or there's a pattern.anytime a game sells relatively poorly the usual folks jump in and blame wokeness or ugly female lead characters etc...yet they never mention that maybe the game overall just wasn't that good...Last of Us 2, Forbidden West all were very solid in terms of sales...yet the wokeness group always needs something to latch onto so they will shift the narrative and say- well it didn't sell as well as the previous game in the series...as if that is some sort of definitive metric
the more games there are in a series the less popular it'll be...same with movies, TV series etc...Cyberpunk 2077 sold extremely well, Forbidden West, Last of Us 2 etc...it's easy to cherry pick certain numbers and twist them to suit whatever narrative you want...Arkham Knight sold less copies then Arkham City...is it because of wokeness or maybe people just didn't like the Batmobile sections and the story
Yeah. If they replaced Tomb Raider with a dude, people would be equally upset.I'm not a God of War fan or have played enough of the game to care.. ( played like 2 )
But I understand why fans are mad. They love Kratos. I love Tomb Raider games.. I'd be super pissed if they replaced Lara Croft and called it a Tomb Raider game.
It has nothing to do with hating on WOMEN.. It's fans of the game not liking games being made by people who AREN'T fans of the series.. Changing a main character that's been in decades of the games is really just insulting.
Yeah. If they replaced Tomb Raider with a dude, people would be equally upset.
Still not getting it..Laufey is Kratos wife...not some random outsider...this new game runs simultaneously in the timeline as the 2018 game
Exactly... a mediocre game rarely sells well no matter what the characters look like, and a good indie game might fare poorly because it's either niche or just doesn't get enough buzz.anytime a game sells relatively poorly the usual folks jump in and blame wokeness or ugly female lead characters etc...yet they never mention that maybe the game overall just wasn't that good...Last of Us 2, Forbidden West all were very solid in terms of sales...yet the wokeness group always needs something to latch onto so they will shift the narrative and say- well it didn't sell as well as the previous game in the series...as if that is some sort of definitive metric
the more games there are in a series the less popular it'll be...same with movies, TV series etc...Cyberpunk 2077 sold extremely well, Forbidden West, Last of Us 2 etc...it's easy to cherry pick certain numbers and twist them to suit whatever narrative you want...Arkham Knight sold less copies then Arkham City...is it because of wokeness or maybe people just didn't like the Batmobile sections and the story
We're all very aware who she is, thanks.Laufey is Kratos wife...not some random outsider...this new game runs simultaneously in the timeline as the 2018 game
I Didn't know I had to be old to appreciate good humor.you guys are showing your age...I bet almost all of the wokeness brigade is over 55 years old...the stereotype of females doing laundry is so outdated and just plain geezer like...these games aren't marketed for the geezer demo
Yes ... that's been discussed here.Saw some guy called this game Laundry lol on Steam Forums.
Pretty much what I wanted to post in my first post here, verbalized.
View: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DZNtqSVTPjF/?igsh=bjdvYnRndGYzODZ2
Key quote here: "It's not about the God of War game playing as a woman, it's why."
That was the most well put together rant about all of the garbage that's happened recently that I've ever seen. If you deny this is happening after watching this, you're being intentionally obtuse.
I knew you'd chime in with absolute nonsense and ignore literally everything that was just presented before you. Thank you for the absolute zero surprise.no one is denying that gay/lesbian/minorities are becoming more prevalent in gaming...it's the why that you're not understanding...those groups were under-represented for years in all forms of media...so yes there is a concerted effort to include them more now...Yes there are now more openly gay game developers, so Yes they would want to create games where there is more of a diverse group of characters...there is not a single AAA game with only gay characters or stories
if you want just White straight men gaming there are thousands of those games...why make a big deal if a small group of games now include them?...the majority is still there for you to play with
Is that really the threshold for you to consider this a legitimate issue? For literally every character to be gay and/or woman?there is not a single AAA game with only gay characters or stories
Again, we don't want to just play as straight white men. We just don't want our existing male-lead games and spaces replaced with women and LGBTs. Or even traditionally asexual female characters (like Lara Croft, or Aloy in Zero Dawn) to suddenly get gay at the end of a game or in their DLC.if you want just White straight men gaming there are thousands of those games...why make a big deal if a small group of games now include them?...the majority is still there for you to play with
Is that really the threshold for you to consider this a legitimate issue? For literally every character to be gay and/or woman?
Women and LGBTs are still way over-represented in the AAA game space, esp. when you consider their actual audience vs. their target audience that aren't playing these games in the first place (please spare us the few exceptions to this if you're thinking otherwise).
Again, we don't want to just play as straight white men. We just don't want our existing male-lead games and spaces replaced with women and LGBTs. Or even traditionally asexual female characters (like Lara Croft, or Aloy in Zero Dawn)to not suddenly get gay at the end of a game or in their DLC.
But as stated in that IG reel, they know they can't get their own games and IPs, because there's no real audience for them and they'll fail like all of the others so far (Forspoken, DA: Veilguard, Concord, Dustborn, etc.) So they have to hijack the existing successful IPs and hope for success still on the backs of beloved male characters who got them there.
Indeed, they would have failed, but likely not to the extent to which they had if they skipped all the forced DEI in the game. But these are largly irrelevant and counter-productive points to the real discussion because nothing can be proven to any convincing degree either way, so there's really no point in bringing this up.you list a group of games that failed because the gameplay sucked...yes the main character in Forspoken also sucked...if she was a man or straight etc the game still would have failed...
Same as above, they likely would have sold better and been more successful if they skipped all the forced DEI characters and messaging into the games. And again, largly irrelevant due to no way to prove if they would or wouldn't have been more successful after changing the games in any way.it has nothing to do with the lead being female...yet you ignore Cyberpunk which had a lot of representation or Forbidden West or Last of Us 2 etc etc...those games may not have sold as well as their predecessors but it has nothing to with wokeness or anything of the sort...LoU 2 killed off one of the main characters...Forbidden West was a step down in story plus it was pretty much the same in terms of gameplay
No, because she's not being turned gay or being replaced by a man as the main character. We've already covered this in the thread.Lara Croft has been in gaming for decades...why no uproar over her?...because she wears revealing outfits?
We're all the same in this respect and I can agree with this. It just seems you're willing to accept the eventual replacement of men in gaming spaces and the significance/impact this can have on our culture overall. I do love a good story to follow in most of the games I play though, which is why many of my favorites are games like the Uncharted series, first TLoU, Horizon ZD, Mass Effect, and the Metal Gear Solid series to name a few. And in those games, their stories are more impactful than any movie to be because of the amount of time you spend in them and the depth of the characters you get to explore as well. And replacing any other those characters' gender or over-sexualizing them by making them gay when it's largely irrelevant to the story only distracts and degrades from the overall story, just the same as it would if they had a straight relationship out of nowhere.I play games for the challenge, combat, environment, graphics etc...does Aloy being gay suddenly change the combat sections of the game?...does it change the exploration?...why does it matter so much?...games are not movies, people are interested in the gameplay over story...most video game stories are nothing special
And replacing any other those characters' gender or over-sexualizing them by making them gay when it's largely irrelevant to the story only distracts and degrades from the overall story, just the same as it would if they had a straight relationship out of nowhere.
Yes, as it detracts from the rest of the story/game and from their DEI message as a whole because it's disenginuous and blatenly forced. So why put in in there other than to virtue signal to that audience who isn't even playing the game? Can you argue as to why it was necessary and benefited to the rest of the game or story? Esp. considering it was with a seemingly throw-away character where it was clear they're parting ways immediatley afterwards?you say any of those characters being gay would be 'irrelevant to the story'...yet when they make Aloy gay you deem it such a major misstep...it's irrelevant to the story of the giant robots and how the world became this way...the Horizon games are not about how Aloy became gay
We're all the same in this respect and I can agree with this. It just seems you're willing to accept the eventual replacement of men in gaming spaces and the significance/impact this can have on our culture overall
So why put in in there other than to virtue signal to that audience who isn't even playing the game? Can you argue as to why it was necessary and benefited to the rest of the game or story? Esp. considering it was with a seemingly throw-away character where it was clear they're parting ways immediatley afterwards?
I'm sure the intended impact is the same as it is in movies or any other media; that' being LGBT is normal or even encouraged because that makes you more "diverse" and diversity is always good.what is the cultural impact this is having on society?...so less straight male main characters in gaming means more men will turn gay?...I enjoy playing as a monkey in Black Myth: Wukong or as an Undead Knight in Dark Souls etc...I could care less if I'm not playing a straight man in a video game
Well real life and telling a curated story are two different things. No one cares about gay people IRL, but inserting them into a story is a completely intentional decision that can be part of character development and (should at least) have an absolute motive to it if you want it to be meaningful. Deciding to add a romance option to a character, esp. when they've largely been asexual throughout the first two main games, is an inherently significant development of a character.why is anyone gay in real life?...it's part of Aloy's story...there's no deep meaning behind it...there are many real life stories of people who are in a short relationship and then part ways...every relationship doesn't lead to a happily ever after marriage...in a post apocalyptic world this is even more understandable
If a man vocally and rpeatedly complains about the sexual attractiveness of a lead female character, he's not doing it because he's interested in her intellect and personal growth.Aurelius
You keep thinking about guys jerking off, who sits around and thinks about that?
I guess it is the right month for it...
https://vgsales.fandom.com/wiki/Horizon
Zero dawn outsold forbidden west
Tsushima is over 13 million sold
Yotei is at 3 million as of the latest update, which was it's first month.
"BuT yotei is NeWeR"
https://www.gamedeveloper.com/busin...s-topped-5-million-sales-in-under-four-months
Tsushima hit 5 million in under 4 months
Wouldn't they brag more if it's still outperforming Tsushima?
Nobody knows the current sales figures for yotei, so your argument holds no water.
Now stop thinking about my wang.
There you go again assuming it's about sexual attraction. It's not. They're making people ugly on purpose, not a 1:1 conversion.If a man vocally and rpeatedly complains about the sexual attractiveness of a lead female character, he's not doing it because he's interested in her intellect and personal growth.
Also, talk about goal post shifting. It remains true that those female-led games outsold other titles available at the same time. For you to make your case, you'd have to show that fewer people were buying the games specifically because men were turned off by those leads and not for other factors (a tough economy, a late-stage console cycle burdened with price hikes, you get the idea).
Me? I'm not saying that people were magnetically drawn to those characters — just that the real-world market for story-driven games isn't driven by the gender or sex appeal of who you play.
chatgpt said:A direct comparison is tricky because Ghost of Yōtei (2025) and Horizon Forbidden West (2022) launched in very different market conditions. But we can compare each game against the major releases from its own launch window.
Ghost of Yōtei (October 2025)
Sony reported that Ghost of Yōtei sold 3.3 million copies in its first month and later said it was outperforming Ghost of Tsushima on a launch-aligned basis. (Gadgets 360)
Compared with major 2025 releases
The takeaway is that Yōtei was one of the biggest premium single-player launches of 2025, though not on the level of the year's absolute blockbuster, Monster Hunter Wilds. Sony described it as a "major hit" and said it materially boosted PS5 hardware sales. (Gadgets 360)
Game Approx. early sales Monster Hunter Wilds Well above 8 million in first few days/months Mario Kart World Multi-million seller tied to Switch 2 launch Ghost of Yōtei 3.3 million in first month Death Stranding 2: On the Beach Lower than Yōtei (no comparable official figure released) Silent Hill f Significantly below Yōtei
Horizon Forbidden West (February 2022)
Sony announced that Horizon Forbidden West reached 8.4 million copies by April 2023, roughly 14 months after launch. (Gematsu)
Its biggest problem was timing: it launched one week before Elden Ring.
Compared with major early-2022 releases
The narrative around Forbidden West is often distorted because Elden Ring overshadowed it critically and culturally. Commercially, however, Forbidden West was still a major success, eventually selling over 8 million copies and becoming one of PlayStation's largest PS5-era franchises. (Gematsu)
Game Sales trajectory Elden Ring 12 million in first few weeks; became a phenomenon Horizon Forbidden West 8.4 million after ~14 months Pokémon Legends: Arceus Over 12 million within months Gran Turismo 7 Strong but below Horizon Dying Light 2 Stay Human Below Horizon long-term
Relative standing in their release windows
If you rank them against their contemporaries:
So, relative to their competition, Ghost of Yōtei appears to have been the stronger performer within its launch window, because there was no Elden Ring-sized phenomenon consuming all the attention. Forbidden West sold very well, but happened to launch next to one of the most successful games of the decade. (Gadgets 360)
Game Relative position among releases of its era Ghost of Yōtei Top-tier hit; among the biggest premium releases of 2025, but behind Monster Hunter Wilds Horizon Forbidden West Top-tier hit commercially, but heavily overshadowed by Elden Ring's unprecedented success
chatgpt said:Below is a **high-confidence version** of the top-selling *new premium console/PC releases* by year. Because publishers often do not disclose exact annual unit sales, I've focused on the games that are generally accepted as the year's biggest new launches and included the best publicly reported figures.
| Year | Game | Release Date | Release-Year Sales (best reported figure) | Lifetime Sales (latest available by 2026) | Source |
| ------------------------ | ------------------------------------------- | ------------ | ------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------- | --------------------------- |
| **2020** | Animal Crossing: New Horizons | 20 Mar 2020 | ~31M in 2020 | 47M+ | Nintendo financial reports |
| | The Last of Us Part II | 19 Jun 2020 | 4M in first 3 days; 10M+ by 2022 | 10M+ | Sony |
| | Ghost of Tsushima | 17 Jul 2020 | 5M+ by Nov 2020 | 13M+ | Sony |
| | Cyberpunk 2077 | 10 Dec 2020 | 13.7M in 2020 | 30M+ | CD Projekt |
| | Assassin's Creed Valhalla | 10 Nov 2020 | Ubisoft's biggest PC launch | Estimated 20M+ players | Ubisoft |
| **2021** | Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl | 19 Nov 2021 | Over 6M in first week worldwide ([Reddit][1]) | 15M+ | Nintendo / Pokémon Co. |
| | Resident Evil Village | 7 May 2021 | 5M+ by launch year | 11M+ | Capcom |
| | Forza Horizon 5 | 9 Nov 2021 | 10M+ players in first week | 40M+ players | Microsoft |
| | Battlefield 2042 | 19 Nov 2021 | Millions sold, exact units undisclosed | — | EA |
| | Metroid Dread | 8 Oct 2021 | Fastest-selling Metroid | 3M+ | Nintendo |
| **2022** | Elden Ring | 25 Feb 2022 | Over 13M within weeks; best-selling new release of 2022 | 30M+ | Bandai Namco / FromSoftware |
| | God of War Ragnarök | 9 Nov 2022 | 11M in first 10 weeks | 15M+ | Sony |
| | Pokémon Scarlet and Violet | 18 Nov 2022 | 10M in first 3 days | 26M+ | Nintendo |
| | Horizon Forbidden West | 18 Feb 2022 | Multi-million seller | 8M+ | Sony |
| | Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II | 28 Oct 2022 | $1B revenue in 10 days | Tens of millions | Activision |
| **2023** | Hogwarts Legacy | 10 Feb 2023 | **22M units sold during 2023** ([Gematsu][2]) | ~40M by late 2025 ([Wikipedia][3]) | Warner Bros. |
| | The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom | 12 May 2023 | 18.5M in ~6 weeks | 21M+ | Nintendo |
| | Marvel's Spider-Man 2 | 20 Oct 2023 | 5M+ in 11 days | 11M+ | Sony |
| | Baldur's Gate 3 | 3 Aug 2023 | Millions sold in 2023 | 15M+ estimated | Larian |
| | Super Mario Bros. Wonder | 20 Oct 2023 | 11.9M in first quarter | 16M+ | Nintendo |
| **2024** | Helldivers 2 | 8 Feb 2024 | 12M by May 2024 ([Gematsu][4]) | 15M+ (public minimum) | Sony |
| | Black Myth: Wukong | 20 Aug 2024 | 20M+ in first month | 25M+ | Game Science |
| | EA Sports College Football 25 | 19 Jul 2024 | One of EA's largest launches | — | EA |
| | Dragon Ball: Sparking! Zero | 11 Oct 2024 | 5M+ | 5M+ | Bandai Namco |
| | Warhammer 40,000: Space Marine 2 | 9 Sep 2024 | 4.5M+ | 6M+ | Focus Entertainment |
| **2025** *(provisional)* | Monster Hunter Wilds | Feb 2025 | Among the year's biggest launches | 10M+ | Capcom |
| | Kingdom Come: Deliverance II | Feb 2025 | Multi-million seller | 3M+ | Embracer / Warhorse |
| | Assassin's Creed Shadows | 2025 | Strong launch, units undisclosed | — | Ubisoft |
| | Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 | 2025 | Multi-million seller | — | Kepler Interactive |
| | Split Fiction | 2025 | Multi-million seller | — | EA |
### Key takeaways
* **2020:** Animal Crossing: New Horizons was the dominant new premium release by a huge margin.
* **2021:** Pokémon Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl appears to have been the largest-selling new premium launch globally based on disclosed sales. ([Reddit][1])
* **2022:** Elden Ring was the clear breakout hit.
* **2023:** Hogwarts Legacy led the entire industry with 22 million units sold during 2023. ([Gematsu][2])
* **2024:** The race was essentially between Helldivers 2 and Black Myth: Wukong, with Wukong ultimately posting the larger unit total.
* **2025:** Rankings remain provisional because many publishers have not yet released audited lifetime sales updates.
If you'd like, I can also build the **full Top 10 list for every year (2020–2025) in spreadsheet-style format with publisher, platform, release-year sales, lifetime sales, and direct source citations for each entry**.
[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/pokemon/comments/rd8o8f?utm_source=chatgpt.com "'Pokémon Brilliant Diamond Shining Pearl' hit six million sales in first week"
[2]: https://www.gematsu.com/2024/01/hogwarts-legacy-sales-top-22-million?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Hogwarts Legacy sales top 22 million - Gematsu"
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hogwarts_Legacy?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Hogwarts Legacy"
[4]: https://www.gematsu.com/2024/05/helldivers-ii-sales-top-12-million?utm_source=chatgpt.com "Helldivers II sales top 12 million - Gematsu"
I actually thought she looked pretty badass in the trailer.
As for the idea that they made her “uglier with no justification,” the story is literally about a family that’s been through years of stress, danger, and — in her case — pregnancy. It makes sense that the character design reflects that.
From a biological standpoint, pregnancy and childbirth can cause long‑term changes to things like muscle distribution, skin elasticity, and facial volume. Men and women also age differently because of hormonal shifts — for example, women experience a sharper drop in estrogen in midlife, which affects skin and bone structure.
So I think folks are saying the way she looks isn’t random or political; it’s consistent with the story and with how real people change over time.
But I also understand the feeling of the game going in far too different of a direction, and the artistic style shifting from a more fantasy look to something more realistic. Of course you are right to feel dissatisfied with the change, or just plain not interested in playing as this character.
"kept the males the same or improved them" no shame in feeling more attracted to the dudes, it is that time of the year I hear...